
Piano Attachment (1899)
U.S. Patent No. 627,739, granted on June 27, 1899, to William J. Nickerson, describes an innovative dual-action acoustic piano attachment designed to function both as a tone-modifier and a pianissimo muffler. Nickerson, an accomplished violinist, conductor, and music educator residing in New Orleans, Louisiana, developed an internal mechanism that could be retrofitted into standard upright pianos without modifying or damaging the instrument’s existing structure.
The invention addressed a key musical need of the late 19th century: allowing pianists to quickly alter tonal textures—such as producing mandolin-like sounds—or mute the volume for quiet practice, all while operating the mechanism smoothly from outside the closed piano case.
The Innovation: The Dual Counterbalanced Apron System
Piano attachments of the era often required permanent structural modifications to the action or cabinet, or forced the pianist to prop open the top lid to make adjustments. Nickerson’s breakthrough was an independent, counterbalanced dual-bar assembly that could be introduced directly into any standard upright piano.
The system utilizes two pivotable bars, each carrying a specialized apron suspended between the piano hammers and the strings:
- The Pianissimo Muffler (Bar D, Apron F): Fitted with felt or similar soft material, this apron cushions the hammer blow against the strings to drastically dampen volume for quiet practice.
- The Tone-Modifier (Bar E, Apron G): Divided into individual tongues (f) backed by thin metallic plates (g) facing the strings. When struck by the hammers, the metallic plates strike the strings, creating bright, percussive timbre alterations reminiscent of a mandolin or zither.
External Control: Counterweights and Protective Shoes
To operate the device without lifting the piano top or marring the finished woodwork, Nickerson engineered an external weighted cord control:
- Tasseled Counterweights (J, K): Cords (H, I) pass out through the natural clearance between the closed lid and the case wall. Heavy counterweights suspend the bars in either an active (horizontal) or inactive (raised/inclined) position. The weights are enclosed in decorative fabric tassels (K) to protect the piano’s polished finish from scratches.
- The Guiding Shoe (L) and Tubes (M): A fitted sheet-metal shoe—finished in nickel or silver—clips over the case wall edge. It incorporates tubular guides (M) that keep the cords separated, untangled, and isolated from contact with the wood.
- Performer-Accessible Routing: In an alternate configuration (Figure 5), the guide shoe and cords are mounted directly to the front wall with guide eyes (t), allowing a seated pianist to drop or raise either apron mid-performance without standing up.
How the Apparatus Functions
The performer can independently engage either device, combine both, or leave the piano in its standard voice:
| Step / Setting | Mechanical Action | Musical & Operational Purpose |
| 1. Standard Piano Voice | Both counterweights are pulled down, raising bars D and E into an inclined rest position. | Hammers strike strings directly; neither apron interferes with normal acoustic playing. |
| 2. Pianissimo (Muffling) | Performer lifts weight H, allowing bar D to fall into a horizontal plane. | Felt apron F drops between hammers and strings, softening the strike for muted practice. |
| 3. Tone Modification | Performer lifts weight I, allowing bar E to drop horizontally. | Apron G positions metallic plates against strings; hammer strikes produce mandolin-like tones. |
| 4. Combined Effect | Both weights H and I are raised, dropping both bars D and E simultaneously. | Produces a muted, softened metallic timbre blending both effects. |
Key Technical Components
- Mounting Brackets (B, C): Bracket B secures pivot pins to the inside of one end wall; slotted bracket C on the opposite wall acts as a vertical guide channel to hold the free ends steady and prevent lateral displacement.
- Muffler Apron (F): A felt strip suspended from bar D that absorbs impact velocity and suppresses upper string harmonics.
- Tone-Modifying Tongues (f, g): Slotted flexible tongues on apron G fitted with metal contact plates (g) on the string-facing side, generating percussive, bright metallic overtones.
- Control Assembly (H, I, J, K, L, M): Independent pull-cords routed through metal tubes on protective shoe L, balanced by decorative weighted tassels K.
Historical and Musical Impact
William J. Nickerson’s patent reflects the vibrant culture of late 19th-century musical innovation and parlor entertainment:
- Non-Invasive Versatility: Pianos were substantial home investments; Nickerson’s attachment provided novelty timbres and practice dampening without drilling into or altering the existing hammer and action geometry.
- Popular Novelty Sounds: At the turn of the 20th century, mandolin, banjo, and zither orchestrations were popular in American parlors; this attachment allowed a single upright piano to simulate multi-instrument ensembles.
- Independent Operation: Unlike integrated third-pedal systems, Nickerson’s independent apron mechanism allowed musicians to select muffling, tone modification, or both simultaneously.
About the Inventor: William J. Nickerson
William J. Nickerson (c. 1865–1928) was a prominent African American classically trained violinist, educator, composer, and orchestra leader in New Orleans, Louisiana.
- Musical Leadership: He led prominent New Orleans ensembles—including Nickerson’s Ladies Orchestra—and was an active figure in elite Creole musical organizations such as the Société des Jeunes-Amis.
- Educator of Jazz Pioneers: Nickerson founded the Nickerson School of Music and taught at Leland University. Among his most famous students was Ferdinand “Jelly Roll” Morton, who studied under Nickerson before helping pioneer early jazz piano.
- Family Legacy: His daughter, Camille Nickerson, went on to become an acclaimed musician, folklorist, and longtime faculty member and music department leader at Howard University.
Summary of Claims
The patent explicitly claims:
- A piano attachment for an upright piano comprising a pivot bracket on one wall, a vertically movable bar carrying an apron interposed between the hammers and strings, an operating cord extending outside the case, and a counterbalance weight.
- The combination of vertically movable apron bars with slotted guiding walls on an opposing bracket to eliminate lateral play.
- A protective metallic shoe engaging the upper rim of the piano wall to guide cords through tubes and prevent wear or scratching of the instrument finish.
- Independent operation of both a sound-muffling apron and a tone-modifying apron using independent cords and counterbalance weights.
